Chip Gaines’ Defends “Family-Friendly” LGBTQ Film

Shiplap royalty and professing Christians, Chip and Joanna Gaines, have produced a new series on their Magnolia Network called “Back to the Frontier,” a series which proudly features a gay couple with two children they’ve purchased.
In his promotion of the show on X, Chip Gaines received a slew of pushback from fellow believers, the very people who helped support and build the Magnolia brand, opposing the stance Gaines initially took and doubled down on.
Alleged Christians Chip and Joanna Gaines showcase gay couple on their new frontier show pic.twitter.com/9dOPeKSSn4
— The Matt Walsh Show (@MattWalshShow) July 14, 2025
In response to the negative reactions he’s received, Chip posted, “Talk, ask [questions,] listen… maybe even learn. Too much to ask of modern American Christian culture. Judge 1st, understand later/never. It’s a sad [Sunday] when ‘non believers’ have never been confronted with hate or vitriol until they are introduced to a modern American Christian.”
I hope this isn’t true, but I read today that Chip and Joanna Gaines are featuring a gay couple in their new series. If It is true, it is very disappointing. While we are to love people, we should love them enough to tell them the truth of God’s Word. His Word is absolute truth.…
— Franklin Graham (@Franklin_Graham) July 12, 2025
“Modern American Christian?” What even is that?
Christianity isn’t a faith that evolves to fit the narrative of the present culture. Why? Because it is founded upon absolute truth and truth cannot be manipulated nor changed.
So-called “modern Christianity” doesn’t exist, and if it did, tolerance would be its main tenant with wokeism as the primary bases of its theology. God’s call to be holy would be ignored and the subject of eternal damnation would be avoided. Some nice Ted Talks would be given in rainbow dressed community centers which once had an empty cross as their symbol but zero transformation or regeneration of the soul would take place.
Thank God this isn’t what Christianity is!
:thread: Chip & Joanna Gaines, Same-Sex Parenting, and the Cost to Kids
— Them Before Us (@ThemBeforeUs) July 13, 2025
Magnolia once stood for faith and family.
Now their new show features a same-sex couple who purchased children via surrogacy, cutting them off from their biological mother.
This isn’t inclusion. It’s injustice. pic.twitter.com/LgtvyQ8cbt
God’s ways and His design for life is perfect, there are no additions, subtractions or alterations that could improve upon His design – this is a reality check for all those who subscribe to the “modern Christianity” belief, a belief which elevates “love” above God when God isn’t just the author of love but the very origination of it!

It’s interesting, many online have pointed to this instance being the capitulation of the Gaines, but this didn’t just happen out of nowhere.
For many ardent followers of their show “Fixer Upper,” the fray began to show back in the Covid era when they started promoting the Covid 19 injections, and then came that little black square. Remember? That black square which stood in solidarity with the outright Marxist group, Black Lives Matter, the same group which stated their intent was to “dismantle the traditional family.”
So ultimately, it seems that Chip and Joanna Gaines were not hiding their true views from the LGBTQ movement, they were hiding them from Christians. https://t.co/LusVeY9fCm
— Megan Basham (@megbasham) July 13, 2025
Tagging on to this, investigative reporter, Megan Basham, unraveled a series of concerning Instagram posts liked and commented on by Joanna Gaines which further point to a shift in their belief system.
The posts in question were posted by an Magnolia employee who professes to be a Christian. The man came out online as “gay” and announced that he would be moving his gay lover into his home to live with him, his wife and his children. To this, Joanna Gaines not only liked the announcement, but replied publicly, “Yes, @billyjackbrawner. You are SO good. We love you :hearts:”

As Conservative commentator, Allie Beth Stuckey, put it, the couple has “exchanged the God of Scripture for the god of self, because you think that you are better and wiser than God is.” And although this story focuses around Chip and Joanna Gaines, it is reflective of where many are in the church in America.
It is expected of the secular world to try and “normalize same-sex couples and families” through entertainment, but followers of Christ? Absolutely not. Endorsing and promoting sin isn’t loving. Normalizing the separation of children from their parents through two gay men purchasing them isn’t “progress” in God’s eyes.
Approving of a “family” structure which demeans and denigrates mother on purpose, as gay unions do, isn’t something to celebrate.
Ultimately, kindness isn’t kind if it’s telling a lie and it looks like the hosts of “Fixer Upper” have some fixing to do.
SUPPORT MATTEA’S WORK
- Tune into The Mattea Merta Podcast
- Follow her on Twitter and Instagram
- Fund the mission through CashApp or PayPal: @matteamerta
CLICK HERE for more posts by Mattea Merta.
Thank you for your support.
If you appreciate the work we do to spread the good news of Jesus Christ, please consider giving a gift to help us continue this work. Maranatha!
Click an icon below to share this post.
All articles, including blogs and guest articles, published on Encounter News are owned by Encounter Today and Encounter News. The use of any content created and published by Encounter News may be quoted but attribution is required.
Portions of Encounter News articles may be used for reprint and republish purposes, but Encounter News MUST BE CREDITED.
All reprinted or republished articles must:
(1) Identify the author of the article.
(2) Contain the Encounter News byline at the beginning of the article and a hyperlink “Encounter News” to the respective article on the Encounter News website.
(3) Contain, at maximum, three paragraphs and then link back to the original article.



















