Olympics’ Controversy: A Glimpse At America Under Kamala Harris?

In the midst of the inspiring athletic performances and emotional Olympic moments in Paris, a troubling narrative has emerged, casting a dark shadow over the Games.

The saga of two boxers has become emblematic of a much broader conflict surrounding gender which has many arguing that women’s competitive spaces are being compromised.

Italy’s Angela Carini made headlines this week when she withdrew from her boxing match after just 46 seconds, suffering a punishing defeat at the hands of Algeria’s Imane Khelif.

Carini, who later described the experience as the hardest she’d ever been hit, voiced her frustration, saying:

“She’s too strong. I didn’t give up, but a punch hurt too much, and so I said I had enough. I go out with my head held high.”

Despite warnings and pressure to withdraw before the bout, Carini’s determination to compete was evident, even as she faced a contest that was completely and utterly unfair and unethical.

Riley Gaines, a prominent women’s sports activist and former NCAA swimmer, expressed deep concern over Carini’s situation:

“It was very clear that this athlete was different than the athletes from the fight before,” Gaines commented, describing Carini as a “hero for every young girl watching.”

The controversy didn’t end here, however.

On Friday, Taiwan’s Lin Yu-ting defeated Uzbekistan’s Sitora Turdibekova in the women’s boxing quarterfinals.

Yu-ting, who had been disqualified from the 2023 World Championships for having XY chromosomes, demonstrated overpowering strength that ultimately led to Turdibekova’s defeat.

Both Yu-ting and Khelif have since clinched medals, further intensifying the debate.

Unlike swimmer “Lia” Thomas, who is openly transgender, Khelif and Yu-ting do not identify as transgender even though they both possess XY chromosomes, suggesting an intersex condition.

Sarah Parshall Perry, a former Senior Counsel to the Department of Education and Senior Legal Fellow at the Heritage Foundation, says:

“Imane Khelif is not transgender, but Intersex. That means he has a likely disorder of sexual development (DSD), and countries like Algeria do not regularly test for these conditions at birth…”

“But with an XY chromosomal structure, high naturally produced testosterone levels, and obvious physical advantages it’s clear he eventually experienced male pubertal development.”

“In biology and blood–things that matter in sports– Khelif is male.”

Regardless of their classification, these two athletes still produce male-level testosterone, giving them a competitive advantage in sports like boxing.

This should make their participation in female divisions extremely problematic.

The International Olympic Committee (IOC) has defended its stance, asserting that all competitors in the women’s category meet the eligibility criteria based on their official documents.

In contrast, the International Boxing Association (IBA) has voiced concerns over the IOC’s inconsistent application of eligibility rules, emphasizing the need for a more standardized approach to ensure competitive fairness and the safety of all athletes.

Allowing individuals with XY chromosomes to compete in women’s sports undermines the integrity of female athletics.

Representative Greg Steube expressed outrage over the situation, condemning the current administration for what he sees as a failure to protect women’s sports.

Steube went on to criticize the Biden administration’s policies, including new Title IX rules, as part of a broader agenda that disregards the safety and fairness for female athletes.

As the debate continues, the stakes for female athletes and the integrity of sports are higher than ever. Whether this controversy will lead to meaningful change or further division remains to be seen, but it is clear that the Paris Olympics have become a focal point in the ongoing struggle over gender and fairness in athletics.

Perspective

The inclusion of athletes who identify as “transgender” in women’s sports is a subject which must be viewed through a biblical lens.

Every human being is made in the image of God which includes an inherent distinction between male and female, with our own divinely ordained roles and characteristics, which should not be altered or redefined by human constructs.

As such, allowing individuals who are biologically male to compete in women’s sports undermines the natural order established by God and challenges the integrity of female athletics.

Whether it is in the workplace, in the boxing ring or when it comes to which restroom individuals are allowed to enter, maintaining rigid distinctions surrounding gender (which is synonymous with sex) is crucial for upholding both Biblical principles which even extends to fairness in competitive sports.

Thank you for your support.

If you appreciate the work we do to spread the good news of Jesus Christ, please consider giving a gift to help us continue this work. Maranatha!